| 1935 |
Jay Berwanger, Chicago, halfback |
| 1936 |
Larry Kelley, Yale, end |
| 1937 |
Clint Frank, Yale, halfback |
| 1938 |
Davey O'Brien, TCU, quarterback |
| 1939 |
Nile Kinnick, Iowa, halfback |
| 1940 |
Tom Harmon, Michigan, halfback |
| 1941 |
Bruce Smith, Minnesota, halfback |
| 1942 |
Frank Sinkwich, Georgia, halfback |
| 1943 |
Angelo Bertelli, Notre Dame, quarterback |
| 1944 |
Les Horvath, Ohio State, quarterback |
| 1945 |
Felix "Doc" Blanchard, Army, fullback |
| 1946 |
Glenn Davis, Army, halfback |
| 1947 |
John Lujack, Notre Dame, quarterback |
| 1948 |
Doak Walker, SMU, halfback |
| 1949 |
Leon Hart, Notre Dame, end |
| 1950 |
Vic Janowicz, Ohio State, halfback |
| 1951 |
Dick Kazmaier, Princeton, halfback |
| 1952 |
Billy Vessels, Oklahoma, halfback |
| 1953 |
John Lattner, Notre Dame, halfback |
| 1954 |
Alan Ameche, Wisconsin, fullback |
| 1955 |
Howard "Hopalong" Cassady, Ohio State, halfback |
| 1956 |
Paul Hornung, Notre Dame, quarterback |
| 1957 |
John David Crow, Texas A&M, halfback |
| 1958 |
Pete Dawkins, Army, halfback |
| 1959 |
Billy Cannon, LSU, halfback |
| 1960 |
Joe Bellino, Navy, halfback |
| 1961 |
Ernie Davis, Syracuse, halfback |
| 1962 |
Terry Baker, Oregon State, quarterback |
| 1963 |
Roger Staubach, Navy, quarterback |
| 1964 |
John Huarte, Notre Dame, quarterback |
| 1965 |
Mike Garrett, USC, halfback |
| 1966 |
Steve Spurrier, Florida, quarterback |
| 1967 |
Gary Beban, UCLA, quarterback |
| 1968 |
O.J. Simpson, USC, halfback |
| 1969 |
Steve Owens, Oklahoma, halfback |
| 1970 |
Jim Plunkett, Stanford, quarterback |
| 1971 |
Pat Sullivan, Auburn, quarterback |
| 1972 |
Johnny Rodgers, Nebraska, halfback-wide receiver |
| 1973 |
John Cappelletti, Penn State, halfback |
| 1974 |
Archie Griffin, Ohio State, halfback |
| 1975 |
Archie Griffin, Ohio State, halfback |
| 1976 |
Tony Dorsett, Pittsburgh, halfback |
| 1977 |
Earl Campbell, Texas, halfback |
| 1978 |
Billy Sims, Oklahoma, halfback |
| 1979 |
Charles White, USC, halfback |
| 1980 |
George Rogers, So. Carolina, halfback |
| 1981 |
Marcus Allen, USC, halfback |
| 1982 |
Herschel Walker, Georgia, halfback |
| 1983 |
Mike Rozier, Nebraska, halfback |
| 1984 |
Doug Flutie, Boston College, quarterback |
| 1985 |
Bo Jackson, Auburn, halfback |
| 1986 |
Vinny Testaverde, Miami, quarterback |
| 1987 |
Tim Brown, Notre Dame, wide receiver |
| 1988 |
Barry Sanders, Oklahoma State, tailback |
| 1989 |
Andre Ware, Houston, quarterback |
| 1990 |
Ty Detmer, Brigham Young, quarterback |
| 1991 |
Desmond Howard, Michigan, wide receiver |
| 1992 |
Gino Torretta, Miami, quarterback |
| 1993 |
Charlie Ward, Florida State, quarterback |
| 1994 |
Rashaan Salaam, Colorado, tailback |
| 1995 |
Eddie George, Ohio State, running back |
| 1996 |
Danny Wuerffel, Florida, quarterback |
| 1997 |
Charles Woodson, Michigan, cornerback |
| 1998 |
Ricky Williams, University of Texas, running back |
| 1999 |
Ron Dayne, Wisconsin, running back |
| 2000 |
Chris Weinke, Florida State, quarterback |
| 2001 |
Eric Crouch, Nebraska, quarterback |
| 2002 |
Carson Palmer, USC, quarterback |
| 2003 |
Jason White, Oklahoma, quarterback |
| 2004 |
Matt Leinart, USC, quarterback |
| 2005 |
Reggie Bush, USC, tailback |
| 2006 |
Troy Smith, Ohio State, quarterback |